Files
intotheeast-com/docs/working/qa/2026-07-08-pre-trip-readiness-audit.md
T
m038andClaude Fable 5 94bfc53b90 docs(working): overnight pre-trip readiness audit + product ideation report
Audit: posting pipeline / auth / API surface review with prioritized P1-P3
findings and a morning checklist; P1-1 (prod 2M upload limit) marked
resolved 2026-07-09 via the CGI->FPM switch in Webmin. Ideation: 7 ranked,
repo-grounded ideas (top pick: OG meta + RSS follow-along stack).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_0195b3cDdMeize2Mm1FgC2aU
2026-07-09 17:59:05 +02:00

171 lines
9.4 KiB
Markdown
Raw Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters
This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.
# Pre-Trip Readiness Audit — 2026-07-08 (overnight)
**Scope:** everything the trip depends on from the road — the posting pipeline
(/post → cache-on-save → add-page-by-form), photo handling, edit mode, auth &
sessions, GPX manager, the custom API surface, and prod's anonymous exposure.
**Method:** read-only code audit of the current `main` + anonymous HTTP probes
against production. **No code was changed.** Findings are prioritized; a
10-minute morning checklist is at the bottom.
---
## What was verified and looks solid ✅
- **Prod anonymous surface holds.** Probed 2026-07-08 (UTC night): `GET
/api/v1/pages` → 401 with a clean JSON error; `/post` and `/gpx-manager`
render the login form; no `X-Powered-By` leak. API CORS is same-origin
(`origins: {}`), rate limiting on (120 req/60s), session auth enabled.
- **The custom API routes are properly hardened.** `entry-actions`
(DELETE entry / reorder photos / trip publish) all require the authenticated
**owner** (`site.owner_username`, not just any login), enforce
`api.pages.write`, validate slugs as safe single segments, and resolve
targets through the page tree via the shared `EntryScopeGuard` — no raw path
concatenation anywhere. The publish route handles the APCu/in-place-write
cache gotcha explicitly and never turns a cache-invalidation failure into a
fake 500. Audit logging on all three.
- **Text can't be lost while composing.** `post-form.js` mirrors every text
field to localStorage on each keystroke and clears the draft **only** on a
server-confirmed success notice. Any failure path (validation error, expired
session, network drop, closed tab) re-offers the text on the next visit.
- **HEIC handling fails closed.** Sniffed from bytes (not filename), converted
client-side, submit is gated while a conversion is in flight, and a failed
conversion skips the file with a visible message instead of uploading a
broken HEIC.
- **Photo reconcile is fail-safe.** Runs exactly once per submit (latched),
an empty/missing `photo_order` touches nothing, only image extensions are
ever deleted, and edit-mode targets resolve through the same scope guard.
- **Edit-mode photo editor has honest error paths.** Failed reorder → revert
to last-known-good; failed refresh after a successful save → keeps the saved
order; failed batch-add → rollback with an explicit warning when rollback
itself was incomplete; 404 on delete treated as convergent success.
- **Cache invalidation on post/edit is correct even under prod caching.**
cache-on-save does `deleteAll()` + `Cache::invalidateCache()` (config
checksum bump → new page-tree index key), so in-place edits appear without
needing APCu-specific clearing on that path.
---
## Findings — do before departure (P1)
### P1-1 · Prod PHP upload limits are unverified — could block photo posting entirely
`php/php-local.ini` (100M upload / 500M post) is **mounted only into the local
Docker container** (`docker-compose.yml`); nothing in `scripts/` or `deploy/`
ships PHP limits to the prod Apache server. If prod runs distro defaults
(`upload_max_filesize=2M` is common), a single modern phone photo (38 MB)
fails to upload — the exact core use case of the trip.
**Action:** `make remote-diag` (or a one-off phpinfo check) to read prod's
`upload_max_filesize` / `post_max_size` / `max_file_uploads`. If low, add a
`.user.ini` (FPM) or `.htaccess` `php_value` (mod_php) via a new make target.
The real proof is P1-2's live post with photos.
> **Resolved 2026-07-09.** Confirmed prod was at the 2M default. Fixed by
> Mischa via Webmin: PHP execution switched from CGI to **PHP-FPM** (package
> was already installed) and the upload limits raised in the FPM
> configuration. Because the setting lives in the server-side FPM config —
> not in the webroot — it survives fresh Grav installs, so no
> `deploy/`-versioned `.user.ini` / make target is needed. Side benefit: APCu
> now persists in shared memory, matching the assumptions in the
> entry-actions publish endpoint's cache invalidation.
> Config location for future reference: Webmin → PHP-FPM Configuration.
> Still owed: P1-2's live phone post is the end-to-end proof.
### P1-2 · One real end-to-end post from the actual phone, on prod, over cellular
The runbook's pre-launch smoke (handover step 7) calls for one `/post` submit
on prod. After the 2026-07-08 deploy, confirm this happened **from the phone
you'll travel with, on cellular, with 2+ HEIC photos** — that exercises HEIC
conversion, FilePond upload, prod PHP limits, cache-on-save under
`twig.cache:true`, and the feed render in one shot. Then edit that entry
(reorder + delete a photo), then delete it — the edit/delete paths shipped
today and deserve one prod rep.
### P1-3 · Session expiry mid-compose: test the 30-minute window once
`system.yaml` has `session.timeout: 1800` (30 min) and `form.yaml` has
`refresh_nonce: false`. A slow entry written on a train can easily outlive the
session; rememberme (enabled, 7-day cookie) should transparently re-auth the
next request, but the form **nonce** and the FilePond **flash uploads** were
created under the old session. The localStorage draft guarantees the text
survives whatever happens — but you should see the actual failure mode once
now, not first in a hostel.
**Test:** open `/post`, add a photo, wait 35+ minutes, submit.
**If it's ugly:** consider raising `session.timeout` in the prod env override
(`deploy/env/prod/system.yaml`, e.g. 412 h) — single-owner site, low risk,
big comfort. (Per-env override, not the committed dev `system.yaml`.)
### P1-4 · Make sure you can log back in from the road
The rememberme cookie lasts **7 days** — on a multi-week trip you *will* be
re-typing the password, possibly on hotel wifi after a cookie wipe. Login
throttling is 5 attempts / 10 min (easy to hit with phone typos).
**Action:** confirm the password is in the phone's password manager and test a
fresh login on the phone once. Know that after 5 typos you wait 10 minutes —
don't panic-retry.
---
## Findings — worth doing before departure (P2)
### P2-1 · Duplicate home page: `user/pages/home/` shadows `00.home/`
Both `user/pages/home/home.md` (old, committed in `a440583`, carries
`routes: default: /`) and `user/pages/00.home/home.md` (the real one) exist
with the same slug and near-identical content — which is exactly why a silent
mix-up would go unnoticed. Which page wins `/home` (the `home.alias` target)
depends on page-index ordering luck.
**Action:** delete `user/pages/home/` (verify `/` and `/home` still render the
context-aware home from `00.home` afterwards, incl. the pre-departure branch).
### P2-2 · Docs drift in CLAUDE.md
- `active_trip: japan-korea-2026` example — that trip doesn't exist; the real
upcoming trip is **`/trips/denmark-2026`** (local `site.yaml`, uncommitted).
- The `entry-actions` plugin (three owner-only API routes, shipped with the
journal-post-form feature) isn't mentioned in CLAUDE.md's plugin list or
architecture sections, and the "post form uses filepond via cache-on-save"
description predates the edit-mode photo editor.
### P2-3 · No HSTS header on prod
Apache serves without `Strict-Transport-Security`. One-line header addition;
the login form and session cookie deserve it (`secure_https: true` is already
set for the cookie).
### P2-4 · Shrink the unused API auth surface
`api.yaml` enables **api_keys + JWT + session** auth. The site only uses
session auth (gpx-manager, post-form edit, entry-actions). If no API keys are
in use (`user/config/plugins/api-private.php` is untracked/local — not
audited), disabling `api_keys_enabled`/`jwt_enabled` in config removes two
whole credential classes from the attack surface. Not urgent — the endpoints
behind them still enforce owner checks.
### P2-5 · Confirm the backup path is live
Every road post only exists on the prod disk until git-sync commits it to
Gitea. **Action:** `make remote-content-status` — confirm git-sync is enabled
on prod and the working tree is clean/pushed. (Photos live under `pages/`, so
they ride along in the content repo — the backup covers them too.)
---
## Known limitations — accepted, no action (P3)
- **Photos are not draft-persisted** (File/Blob can't go to localStorage); the
restore hint says so explicitly. Re-selecting photos after a failure is the
designed trade-off.
- **Location/weather helpers depend on free third-party APIs** (BigDataCloud
reverse-geocode, Open-Meteo). Both are best-effort with manual fallbacks —
fine.
- **No offline mode.** `/post` needs connectivity to load; composing offline
means the phone's notes app. (Logged as an ideation candidate, not a bug.)
- **Rate limit 120 req/60s** is generous for a single owner; a 6-photo edit
batch stays far below it.
---
## Morning checklist (~10 minutes + one coffee)
1. `make remote-diag` → check `upload_max_filesize` / `post_max_size` on prod
(P1-1). Fix limits first if they're at defaults.
2. From the phone, on cellular, on prod: log in fresh → post a test entry with
2 HEIC photos → verify it's in the feed immediately → edit it (reorder +
remove a photo) → delete it (P1-2, P1-4).
3. `make remote-content-status` → git-sync clean and pushing (P2-5).
4. Optional but cheap: start the 35-minute `/post` session-expiry test in a
background tab while doing the above (P1-3).
5. Queue the P2 cleanups (duplicate home folder, CLAUDE.md drift, HSTS) for a
normal dev session — none block departure.